Share, Research, Rate: Watches & Collections
v7.3 (A.I. Watch & Collection Reviews)
Follow for Updates:
10 - Seiko / Seiko / Seiko / Seiko / Seiko / Seiko / Swatch / Swatch / Swatch / Swatch - 202411091158
rue_mo_has_it
Collector:
Collector Description
Top 10 after 4 years. Used to be all Seikos until last year. Totally gave in to the Swatch collaborations. I’ve decided to stop for now to save up for a higher end one in time for my 40th but I still can’t decide between an Omega Speedmaster, Tudor Black Bay, or Grand Seiko.
A.I. Watch Collection Review
7.8
### Collection Review: 10 Watches - Seiko (70%) / Swatch (30%)
#### % Exposure by Style
1. **Diver**: 30% - Seiko SKX009 Scuba Pepsi, Seiko Prospex Sea Save the Ocean, Swatch Blancpain x Swatch Ocean of Storms
2. **Sport**: 30% - Seiko 5 Sports Automatic Flieger, Seiko Prospex Speedtimer Quartz Solar, Swatch Blancpain x Swatch Indian Ocean
3. **Dress**: 20% - Seiko Presage Open Heart Blue Dial, Seiko Prospex Alpinist Automatic SBDC117
4. **Chronograph**: 10% - Swatch Moonswatch Mission to Pluto
5. **Casual**: 10% - Swatch Moonswatch Mission to Earthphase
#### % Exposure by Movement
1. **Automatic**: 60% - Seiko Presage Open Heart Blue Dial, Seiko Prospex Alpinist Automatic SBDC117, Seiko SKX009 Scuba Pepsi, Seiko Prospex Sea Save the Ocean, Seiko 5 Sports Automatic Flieger, Swatch Blancpain x Swatch Ocean of Storms
2. **Quartz Solar**: 20% - Seiko Prospex Speedtimer Quartz Solar, Swatch Blancpain x Swatch Indian Ocean
3. **Quartz**: 20% - Swatch Moonswatch Mission to Pluto, Swatch Moonswatch Mission to Earthphase
---
#### Overall Collection Rating: 7.8/10
This collection offers a broad range of styles and movement types, appealing to various settings, from casual and sports to dress and diving. Seiko's dominance reflects a focus on functionality and versatile Japanese timepieces, while the Swatch pieces add eclectic and modern touches.
---
### Breakdown by Collection Metrics
- **Brand (10% Weight): 7.5/10**
The collection is well-represented by Seiko, a brand recognized for reliable craftsmanship and design diversity, with Swatch offering lighter, accessible options.
- **History & Innovation (10% Weight): 7.0/10**
The historical significance of Seiko’s contributions, especially with models like the Alpinist and Prospex, strengthens the collection. Swatch’s Moonswatch editions add contemporary cultural appeal.
- **Rarity (10% Weight): 6.5/10**
Limited editions such as the Swatch Blancpain x Swatch series and unique colorway models add a modest level of rarity to the collection, though most pieces are not highly exclusive.
- **Material (10% Weight): 6.8/10**
The collection primarily features stainless steel cases, but the Swatch Blancpain x Swatch and Moonswatch models add distinctive materials like Bioceramic.
- **Movement (10% Weight): 7.5/10**
The automatic models provide robust mechanical options, while the solar and quartz models add functionality. There is a decent depth in movement diversity with automatics, solar, and quartz.
- **Versatility (10% Weight): 8.0/10**
The collection spans a variety of use cases, from diving and sports to dress occasions. However, an even wider range of complications could enhance functional adaptability.
- **Complications (10% Weight): 7.0/10**
While the collection covers basic and sports features, a broader range of high-end complications, such as GMT or chronographs, would add depth. The Speedtimer and Earthphase add some diversity.
- **Functions (10% Weight): 8.0/10**
The Seiko and Swatch divers contribute good water resistance, while the Seiko Presage adds an open-heart display. The solar-powered models provide convenient maintenance-free functionality.
- **Dials & Design (10% Weight): 8.5/10**
Each piece exhibits unique design elements, from the Seiko Alpinist’s textured dial to the vivid colors of the Moonswatch collection. The collection provides a visually appealing and varied aesthetic.
- **Cohesiveness (10% Weight): 7.3/10**
The collection has a unified emphasis on practical and accessible designs, yet the contrasting styles between Seiko’s heritage and Swatch’s playful aesthetics create a balanced but eclectic feel.
---
### Collection Strengths and Potential Areas for Improvement
- **Strengths**:
- Strong variety in affordable, quality watches, with reliable Seiko automatics complemented by playful Swatch designs.
- High versatility across diverse styles and purposes.
- Visually engaging, with a mix of traditional and modern design approaches.
- **Areas for Improvement**:
- Consider adding a high-end or luxury timepiece for depth and exclusivity.
- Introduce more complication-rich models (e.g., GMT, perpetual calendar) to broaden functional appeal.
- Additional variety in materials would improve overall quality and presentation.
---
### Watch-by-Watch Summary
1. **Seiko Presage Open Heart Blue Dial** - $550
- **Overall Rating**: 7.9/10
- Brand (7.5), History & Innovation (7.0), Rarity (6.8), Material (7.0), Movement (8.2), Versatility (8.0), Complications (7.2), Functions (7.5), Dials & Design (8.6)
- Classic dress watch with an open-heart display; great choice for formal settings.
2. **Seiko Prospex Alpinist Automatic SBDC117** - $700
- **Overall Rating**: 8.0/10
- Brand (7.8), History & Innovation (7.5), Rarity (6.9), Material (7.2), Movement (8.5), Versatility (8.3), Complications (7.4), Functions (8.1), Dials & Design (8.0)
- A versatile automatic with historical significance and outdoor-oriented design.
3. **Seiko SKX009 Scuba Pepsi** - $400
- **Overall Rating**: 8.2/10
- Brand (8.0), History & Innovation (8.0), Rarity (7.1), Material (7.5), Movement (8.3), Versatility (8.5), Complications (7.5), Functions (8.5), Dials & Design (8.0)
- Highly regarded diver with Pepsi bezel, excellent for sports and diving use.
4. **Seiko Prospex Sea Save the Ocean** - $475
- **Overall Rating**: 8.0/10
- Brand (7.8), History & Innovation (7.5), Rarity (7.0), Material (7.5), Movement (8.1), Versatility (8.5), Complications (7.3), Functions (8.4), Dials & Design (8.1)
- Robust diver with an ocean-inspired dial, strong functionality and legibility.
5. **Seiko 5 Sports Automatic Flieger** - $250
- **Overall Rating**: 7.5/10
- Brand (7.3), History & Innovation (7.0), Rarity (6.5), Material (6.8), Movement (7.8), Versatility (8.0), Complications (6.5), Functions (7.7), Dials & Design (7.7)
- Casual yet sporty design; accessible choice for entry-level mechanical watch enthusiasts.
6. **Seiko Prospex Speedtimer Quartz Solar** - $350
- **Overall Rating**: 7.3/10
- Brand (7.0), History & Innovation (6.8), Rarity (6.3), Material (6.8), Movement (7.5), Versatility (7.8), Complications (6.5), Functions (8.0), Dials & Design (7.5)
- Functional chronograph with solar power, suitable for daily sports wear.
7. **Swatch Moonswatch Mission to Pluto** - $260
- **Overall Rating**: 7.2/10
- Brand (7.0), History & Innovation (7.5), Rarity (6.8), Material (6.5), Movement (6.0), Versatility (7.5), Complications (6.2), Functions (7.0), Dials & Design (8.0)
- Unique quartz chronograph; standout in design, appealing for casual wear.
8. **Swatch Moonswatch Mission to Earthphase** - $280
- **Overall Rating**: 7.0/10
- Brand (6.8), History & Innovation (7.0), Rarity (6.3), Material (6.2), Movement (6.0), Versatility (7.3), Complications (6.2), Functions (6.5), Dials & Design (7.8)
- Earth-inspired colors make it an interesting addition with a playful design.
9. **Swatch Blancpain x Swatch Ocean of Storms** - $300
- **Overall Rating**: 7.4/10
- Brand (7.5), History & Innovation (7.8), Rarity (7.2), Material (6.8), Movement (6.5), Versatility (7.2), Complications (6.5), Functions (7.2), Dials & Design (8.2)
- Bioceramic dive
watch with historical tie-in, modern and accessible design.
10. **Swatch Blancpain x Swatch Indian Ocean** - $300
- **Overall Rating**: 7.5/10
- Brand (7.6), History & Innovation (7.8), Rarity (7.0), Material (6.9), Movement (6.5), Versatility (7.4), Complications (6.6), Functions (7.2), Dials & Design (8.0)
- Inspired design with a focus on marine themes, casual and water-friendly.
---
_A.I. WatchMetrics Review v7.3_