Share, Research, Rate: Watches & Collections
v7.3 (A.I. Watch & Collection Reviews)
Follow for Updates:
6 - Tag Heuer / Tudor / Rolex / Swatch / BA1110D / Orient - 202411150136
DF_Anonymous
Collector:
Collector Description
Started seriously collecting around 6 years ago. I am currently looking for a dress watch (or dressy type, I am not set solely on one specific type of watch). In mind, I have the Hamilton Murph 38mm and the Lacao Valencia 39mm. Any recommendations appreciated!
A.I. Watch Collection Review
8.2
### **6-Watch Collection Review: Rolex (17%) / Tudor (17%) / Tag Heuer (17%) / Orient (17%) / Swatch (17%) / BA1110D (17%)**
---
### **Overall Collection Rating: 8.2/10**
This collection offers a diverse mix of styles and brands, covering tool, dress, and avant-garde aesthetics. With iconic names like Rolex, Tudor, and Tag Heuer, balanced by accessible brands like Orient and Swatch, the collection reflects versatility and global appeal. It is ideal for enthusiasts valuing variety, from formal to casual occasions, and innovative designs.
---
### **% Exposure by Style**
- **Dress**: 33% (Rolex Datejust II / Orient Bambino V2 Small Seconds)
- **Tool**: 33% (Tudor Black Bay Ceramic / Tag Heuer Formula 1 Chronograph)
- **Avant-Garde**: 17% (BA1110D Chapter 7.1)
- **Casual/Sport**: 17% (Swatch Moonswatch Mission to the Moon)
---
### **% Exposure by Movement**
- **Automatic**: 50% (Rolex Datejust II / Tudor Black Bay Ceramic / Orient Bambino V2 Small Seconds)
- **Quartz**: 33% (Tag Heuer Formula 1 Chronograph / Swatch Moonswatch Mission to the Moon)
- **Other**: 17% (BA1110D Chapter 7.1)
---
### **Breakdown by Watch Collection Metrics**
- **Brand (11.1%)**: 8.5
The collection is anchored by renowned names like Rolex and Tudor, with balanced inclusions of accessible and experimental brands like Orient and BA1110D.
- **History & Innovation (11.1%)**: 8.3
The Rolex and Tudor pieces embody heritage and technical prowess. The BA1110D and Swatch add innovative flair with their unique approaches.
- **Rarity (11.1%)**: 7.8
While Rolex and Tudor provide exclusivity, the collection includes more accessible options like the Swatch and Orient, slightly reducing the rarity factor.
- **Material (11.1%)**: 8.5
High-quality materials like ceramic in the Tudor and stainless steel in the Rolex boost the score, while the plastic case of the Swatch lowers it slightly.
- **Movement (11.1%)**: 8.4
A mix of robust quartz and reliable automatic movements ensures variety and dependability.
- **Versatility (11.1%)**: 8.6
The collection covers multiple occasions, from formal events (Rolex Datejust II) to outdoor adventures (Tudor Black Bay Ceramic).
- **Complications (11.1%)**: 8.0
Chronographs, date functions, and ceramic bezels diversify functionality, though there is no highly advanced complication.
- **Functions (11.1%)**: 8.2
Water resistance and precise chronographs contribute positively, though the Swatch is limited in technical performance.
- **Dials & Design (11.1%)**: 8.8
Each watch stands out with distinct and cohesive designs, from the timeless Rolex Datejust II to the modern and playful Swatch.
- **Cohesiveness (11.1%)**: 7.5
While diverse, the collection spans various price points and purposes, slightly impacting overall thematic unity.
---
### **Collection Strengths**
1. **Diverse Styles**: Covers dress, tool, and casual categories effectively.
2. **Balanced Prestige and Accessibility**: Combines luxury (Rolex, Tudor) with accessible brands (Swatch, Orient).
3. **Innovation and Tradition**: BA1110D and Swatch add a modern twist to a collection rooted in traditional watchmaking.
---
### **Potential Areas for Improvement**
1. **Focus on Cohesiveness**: Adding a unifying theme, like a shared complication or style, could improve harmony.
2. **Explore Advanced Complications**: Including a perpetual calendar or GMT would elevate the collection's technical depth.
3. **Expand Avant-Garde**: More experimental designs could balance the classic-heavy lineup.
---
### **Watch-by-Watch Summary**
1. **Rolex Datejust II 41 116334 (8.8/10)**
- **Brand (9.5)**, **Material (9.2)**, **Dials & Design (9.0)**
A quintessential dress watch with timeless elegance, featuring a 41mm steel case and white gold fluted bezel.
2. **Tudor Black Bay Ceramic (8.5/10)**
- **Material (9.0)**, **Rarity (8.5)**, **Functions (8.6)**
A robust diver's watch with ceramic construction and a COSC-certified movement.
3. **Tag Heuer Formula 1 Chronograph CAU111E.FT6024 (8.0/10)**
- **Complications (8.3)**, **Versatility (8.5)**, **Movement (8.0)**
A sporty quartz chronograph with a bold design and everyday wearability.
4. **Swatch Moonswatch Mission to the Moon (7.8/10)**
- **Brand (7.5)**, **History & Innovation (7.8)**, **Dials & Design (8.0)**
A playful take on Omega's Speedmaster with lightweight materials and whimsical appeal.
5. **BA1110D Chapter 7.1 (8.0/10)**
- **Innovation (8.5)**, **Avant-Garde Style (8.5)**, **Material (7.8)**
An unconventional piece emphasizing mechanical transparency and independent watchmaking.
6. **Orient Bambino V2 Small Seconds (8.2/10)**
- **Dials & Design (9.0)**, **Versatility (8.5)**, **Movement (8.3)**
A refined and affordable dress watch with a vintage aesthetic and small seconds complication.
---
### **Conclusion**
This collection delivers a strong mix of tradition, innovation, and affordability, making it ideal for a collector who values variety and style. With some additional focus on advanced complications or thematic unity, this already impressive lineup could become even more compelling.
---
*Footnote: A.I. WatchMetrics Review v.7.3*